Friday, April 26, 2024

Closed vs. Open back headphones: Which should you buy?

Share

grado-gw100-review-2.jpg?itok=hPnCiirt

Best answer: Open back headphones don’t have a solid construction for the ear cup and instead have cut-outs for ventilation and to expand the “soundstage.” This means the sound will leak through and they aren’t ideal where others won’t appreciate your tunes. But oh boy do they sound good!

  • Amazon: Grado GW100 Bluetooth Headphones ($249)
  • Amazon: Panasonic Premium Hi-Res Wireless Headphones ($250)

Wide open spaces

Open back headphones are exactly what you picture when you read those words — headphones where the rear, behind the speaker assembly (known as the driver) is facing away from your head and is open. Not completely open of course, but not sealed in like closed back headphones. Usually associated with on-ear or over-ear headphones (though there are open back earbuds?tag=androidcentralb-20&ascsubtag=UUacUdUnU70657) having an open back offers makes three important differences:

  • Your ears don’t get as sweaty.
  • People close to you can hear what you’re listening to once you turn things up a little loud. And not really loud, just a little loud.
  • The space used to move the sound waves from the driver to your ears isn’t as confined, resulting in a bigger “soundstage.”

The first two are pretty obvious. Instead of being closed up inside a plastic cup, your ears can get a little bit of air when there are vents and someone sitting next to you can hear whatever you can hear if they are close to your head or if you have it turned up loud enough. Don’t wear open back headphones to the library. Of course, this can have an advantage, too. You can hear traffic noise while wearing open back headphones unless you’ve turned things up to 11, which is why a lot of folks who cycle wear them.

Soundstage is something you might have heard before when people talk about headphones or speakers, and it’s not a complicated idea to wrap your head around. If you have a pair of good noise-canceling headphones on and have the volume up a good amount you can feel exactly where the sound is coming from. That’s a small soundstage. With open back headphones, it can feel like the sound is coming from further away and there is more depth — things can sound closer or further away even though the volume is the same — and that’s a bigger soundstage. It’s a personal preference thing, but generally, a bigger soundstage will sound more pleasing than a smaller one. It also matters for particular types of music — jazz and classical, for instance, often sound better through headphones with a wider soundstage because instruments are placed more deliberately apart.

panasonic-rp-hd605n-review-1.jpg?itok=Iq

Which is for me?

That all depends on where and how you want to listen, and what you want to listen to.

I already mentioned that open back headphones probably aren’t great to wear at the library. Add the bus, a train, an airplane, or any other place where there is a good chance someone will be sitting next to you to that list. Trust me, they will hear what you hear and might not like it. Don’t be that person.

Open back headphones also aren’t great in situations where you want some noise cancellation. A roaring jet engine is just as roaring while wearing open back headphones as it is while not wearing any headphones. They’re also not very good for making or taking calls, for all the reasons above.

Where they excel, though, is when you’re listening to your favorite music or a movie or show at a moderate volume and relaxing. The depth effect that open back headphones provide really can bring music alive and a benefit of a bigger deeper soundstage is being able to hear things you might have otherwise missed, like the ring of acoustic guitar strings or just how awesome Mariah Carey’s vocal range is. You don’t have to be an audiophile to appreciate it when music or a movie sounds better.

Open back

Grado GW100 Bluetooth Headphones

grado-gw100-render.jpg?itok=BbnPv4xb

$249 at Amazon

Legendary sound with no wires

Grado has been long known for having incredible sound quality at a great price. the GW100 model brings these features to Bluetooth headphones, and you’ll hear the difference.

Closed back

Panasonic Premium Hi-Res Wireless Headphones

panasonic-hi-res-render.jpg?itok=rXTY5w2

$250 at Amazon

Best budget headphones

They might not have the brand cache that Bose or Sony does when it comes to noise-canceling headphones, but these Panasonic Hi-Res cans deliver where it counts — comfort and sound quality.

Read more

More News