Peer review is a key component of scientific publication. While imperfect, numerous studies have demonstrated that peer review improves the quality of manuscripts.1,2,3,4 There have been several interventions to improve peer review quality that have yielded mixed results, for example, blinding reviewers to author identity, using statistical checklists, or conducting reviewer training.5 Several studies have shown that reviewer ratings have low inter-rater reliability and only a limited ability to predict the eventual impact of articles.6,7,8
We at JGIM use a three-stage process. First, the co-editors in chief evaluate submissions for fit and quality. About 40% of articles are rejected at this stage. Those who pass this initial review are sent to one of the deputy editors for a secondary, in-depth screen. Deputy editors can reject the article, accept as is, or send out for external review. At each stage, we ask, “is it new, is it true, will it change practice and is the writing clear?”
We ask peer reviewers to identify scientific strengths and weakness and assess the likely impact on the field of general internal medicine and if the article is clearly written. While we ask reviewers to make recommendations regarding acceptance, we are mindful of the unreliability of this process2 and use these recommendations as only one element in what is ultimately an editorial decision. Many good papers are returned to authors with regrets, and we have rejected some important and impactful work.7 Peer reviewers, editors, and the editorial process are all fallible. We are grateful to authors who continue to submit to the journal, hoping that we finally get it right. The good news is that most articles rejected at JGIM are eventually accepted at another journal, so never say die!
JGIM could not exist without the tireless energy and effort expended by our cadre of deputy editors. We thank them for their continued, voluntary effort to improve our journal. The debt we owe our deputy editors cannot be repaid. If you have an interest in joining this exciting, passionate group, please feel free to email any of the editors.
JGIM would also like to thank the many talented people who have volunteered their time to serve as peer reviewers for the journal over the past 12 months. In 2017–2018, 958 reviewers provided a total of 1188 reviews with a mean quality score of 4.3 on a scale of 1–6 (as judged by our JGIM deputy editors). Of these, 210 provided at least two reviews, and 23 provided three or more. We are indebted to them for their service. If you are not currently reviewing for JGIM, please consider signing up at JGIM.org.
Among this group of dedicated peer reviewers, there is a group that stands out. These top peer reviewers performed at least two reviews between July 2017 and June 2018, returned all reviews within 30 days, and received a quality score of 4 or greater (out of a maximum score of 6) on all reviews. An asterisk identifies the 114 reviewers who meet these criteria. We congratulate them on their service to the academic community and thank them for their efforts on behalf of the journal.
JGIM Reviewers, 2017–2018
Adams, E.Kathleen | |
Adesoye, Taiwo | |
Adnan, Azreen | |
Adsul, Prajakta | |
Afarideh, Mohsen | |
Agarwal, Krishna | |
Agarwal, Nitendra | |
Ahmed, Ali | |
Ahmed, Andaleeb | |
Akgun, Kathleen | |
Alba, Diana | |
Albert, Tyler | |
Allen, Heidi | |
Allen, Kelli | |
Allyse, Megan | |
Almehmi, Ammar | |
Alsabbagh, Wasem | |
Alvarez, Carmen | |
Amer, Abdulrahman | |
Ammannagari, Nischala | |
Amy, Christine | |
Anderson, David* | |
Anderson, Mary | |
Andrews, Mary | |
Andrews, Rebecca | |
Anstett, Tyler | |
Apaydin, Eric | |
Applebaum, Robert | |
Arnold, Louise | |
Arora, Gitanjli* | |
Ashworth, Julie | |
Assoumou, Sabrina | |
Athavale, Ambarish | |
Atkinson, Tim | |
Atlas, Steven | |
Auerbach, David | |
Auriemma, Catherine | |
Aylward, Michael | |
Ayyala, Manasa | |
Bachhuber, Marcus | |
Bade, Brett | |
Baer, Heather | |
Bagchi, Ann | |
Bagley, Sarah | |
Bailey, F. Amos | |
Bailey, Steffani | |
Balkrishnan, Rajesh | |
Banach, David* | |
Banderudrappagari, Rajesh | |
Bansal, Ankush | |
Barelski, Adam | |
Barish, Peter* | |
Barnas, Gary | |
Barnes, Geoffrey | |
Barnes, Hilary* | |
Barnett, Michael* | |
Barry, Declan | |
Barry, Michael | |
Bartfeld, Judith | |
Basu, Nisha | |
Bates, Sarah | |
Batsis, John | |
Battistone, Michael | |
Bawa, Rashmi | |
Becker, William* | |
Beckman, Thomas | |
Beehler, Gregory | |
Bender, Ryan Elizabeth | |
Benitez, Joseph | |
Benzer, Justin | |
Berger, Gabrielle | |
Bergus, George | |
Berkowitz, Seth* | |
Berlowitz, Dan | |
Bernhardt, Barbara* | |
Bernstein, Lisa | |
Bernstein, Steven | |
Berruti, Andres | |
Bertisch, Suzanne | |
Berz, Jonathan | |
Bhandare, Deepti | |
Bhanegaonkar, Abhijeet | |
Bhattacharya, Priyanka | |
Bhome, Rohan | |
Bilal, Usama | |
Birken, Sarah | |
BiswasRoy, Sreeja | |
Blagojevic-Bucknall, Milica | |
Blalock, Dan* | |
Blanchard, Janice* | |
Blanchard, Rebecca | |
Block, Lauren | |
Blosnich, John | |
Blumenthal, Daniel | |
Bodenheimer, Thomas | |
Bogowicz, Paul | |
Bollinger, Mary | |
Bonifacino, Eliana | |
Boudreaux, Michel | |
Bouldin, Erin | |
Bounthavong, Mark | |
Bowen, Deborah | |
Boxer, Richard | |
Boyd, Andrew | |
Bradley, Katharine | |
Braillard, Olivia | |
Brandt, Cynthia | |
Brantley, Erin | |
Brar, Jaspreet | |
Brauner, Daniel | |
Breckons, Matthew | |
Briot, Pascal | |
Brockmeyer, Diane | |
Broers, Barbara | |
Bromley, Elizabeth* | |
Bronstein, Janet | |
Brook, Robert | |
Brooks, Robert | |
Bruce, Martha | |
Brunner, Julian | |
Buchbinder, Mara | |
Buczko, William | |
Burgo-Black, Lucile | |
Burke, Robert* | |
Burke, Wylie | |
Butterly, John | |
Bynum, William | |
Cain, Jeff | |
Caines, Laurie | |
Campos, Claudia* | |
Carmichael, Kim | |
Carney, Patricia | |
Carroll, Norman | |
Caruso, John | |
Chakkalakal, Rosette | |
Challa, Hima | |
Chandra, Ramesh | |
Chanfreau, Catherine | |
Chang, Evelyn | |
Chatterjee, Avik | |
Chaubey, Vinod | |
Chemitiganti, Ramachandra Rahul | |
Chen, Kenneth | |
Chen, Min | |
Cherkin, Dan | |
Chi, Jeffrey | |
Cho, Hyung | |
Chokshi, Dave | |
Chou, Calvin | |
Chowdhry, Saleem | |
Christoph, Mary* | |
Christopher, Myra | |
Chung, Yoonkyung | |
Ciechanowski, Paul | |
Cipriano, Lauren | |
Clauw, Daniel | |
Clemons, Julia | |
Clough, Jeffrey | |
Coburn, Andrew | |
Coburn, Andrew | |
Cole, Allison | |
Cole, Megan | |
Coleman-Jensen, Alisha | |
Combellick, Joan | |
Comi, Richard | |
Compton, Peggy | |
Concato, John | |
Conde, Michele | |
Cornia, Paul* | |
Corral, Janet | |
Correa, Ashish* | |
Costa, Daniel | |
Crane, Melissa | |
Cremer, Miriam | |
Crews, Deidra | |
Cronkite, Ruth | |
Crotty, Bradley | |
Cummings-Vaughn, Lenise | |
Cunningham, Amy | |
Cunningham, Chinazo | |
Curran, Donald | |
Curry, William | |
Cvengros, Jamie | |
D’amore, John | |
Dalton, Jarrod | |
Damp, Julie | |
Damschroder, Laura | |
Danan, Elisheva | |
Daneschvar, Homayoun | |
Danis, Marion | |
Datta, Santanu | |
Davidson, Heather | |
Davis, Elizabeth | |
DeFer, Thomas | |
Deber, Raisa | |
Decamp, Lisa | |
Decker, Sandra | |
Denson, Joshua* | |
Derose, Kathryn | |
Derycke, Eric | |
Dewalt, Darren | |
Dewitt, Dawn | |
Diaz Del Carpio, Roberto | |
Dinardo, Deborah | |
Dobscha, Steven* | |
Doctor, Jason | |
Documet, Patricia | |
Dolansky, Mary | |
Done, Nicolae* | |
Dorr, David | |
Douglas, Vanja | |
Douketis, Jim | |
Dowell, Deborah | |
Drake, Jonathan | |
Du, Yu | |
Duberstein, Paul | |
Dumeus, Stanley | |
Dutton, Gareth | |
Dyer, Karen | |
Dyrbye, Liselotte | |
Dzeng, Elizabeth | |
Earnest, Mark | |
Eberhart, Nicole | |
Edelman, E. Jennifer | |
Eder, Milton | |
Edgman-Levitan, Susan | |
Edwards, Samuel* | |
Eidson-Ton, W. Suzanne | |
Ekpenyong, Andem | |
El-Kareh, Robert* | |
Eliacin, Johanne | |
Ellenbogen, Michael | |
Ellis, Shellie | |
Elwy, Rani* | |
Eng, Jessica | |
Erickson, Jeanne | |
Fagan, Mark | |
Farmer, Melissa* | |
Farnan, Jeanne | |
Feddock, Christopher | |
Federman, Alex | |
Felter, Elizabeth | |
Feng, Bo | |
Fernandez, Leonor | |
Fingerhood, Michael | |
Finkel, Madelon | |
Finley, Erin | |
Fisher, Frederick* | |
Fitzgerald, April | |
Fix, Gemmae | |
Fletcher, CarolE | |
Fletcher, Robert | |
Flieger, Signe Peterson | |
Flory, James | |
Flythe, Jennifer | |
Fox, Aaron | |
Frakt, Austin | |
Fralick, Michael | |
Frank, Joseph | |
Frank, Maria | |
Frankel, Richard | |
Franklin, Gary* | |
Fritz, Julie | |
Furman, Andrew | |
Gagliardi, Jane | |
Gajendran, Mahesh | |
Galanter, William | |
Galbraith, Alison | |
Gamble, John-Michael | |
Ganguli, Ishani | |
Ganz, David | |
Garcia, Maria* | |
Gardner, Rebekah | |
Garg, Megha* | |
Garla, Vishnu | |
Garnick, Deborah | |
Garrison, Scott | |
Gaston, Symielle* | |
Gawron, Lori | |
Gaylin, Daniel | |
Geha, Rabih | |
George, Gemy | |
Ghajar, Alireza* | |
Giannitrapani, Karleen | |
Gierisch, Jennifer | |
Girard, Donald | |
Giulii Capponi, Michela | |
Given, Charles | |
Glassman, Peter | |
Glassman, Rebecca | |
Gleason, Jessica* | |
Glied, Sherry | |
Glowinski, Anne | |
Gnanaraj, Jerome | |
Goldhaber-Fiebert, Sara | |
Goldman Rosas, Lisa | |
Goldstein, Karen | |
Goodman, Michael | |
Gopalan, Anjali | |
Gossa, Weyinshet | |
Grady, Christine | |
Graves, Kencee* | |
Gray, Kristen | |
Green, Lee | |
Greenblatt, Aaron | |
Greeson, Jeffrey | |
Gross, Georgina* | |
Grosse, Scott | |
Grossman, Ellie | |
Grover, Michael | |
Guihan, Marylou | |
Gulati, Swati | |
Gupta, Ankit | |
Gupta, Navdeep* | |
Gupta, Ridhi | |
Gupta, Sonu* | |
Guy, Michelle | |
Hagiwara, Nao | |
Hajek, André | |
Hajji, Raouf | |
Halalau, Alexandra | |
Halkar, Meghana | |
Hamel, Lauren | |
Hamer, Davidson | |
Hammond, W. Ed | |
Handel, Dan | |
Hansen, Ryan | |
Hanyok, Laura | |
Harmata, Rita | |
Harrison, R. Van | |
Harrison, James | |
Harry, Elizabeth | |
Hart, Laura | |
Hartzell, Joshua | |
Haw, Jeehea | |
Hay, Seonaid | |
Headrick, Jennifer | |
Heapy, Alicia | |
Hebert, Paul | |
Henry, Stephen | |
Henson, James | |
Heppe, Dan* | |
Herbst, Jeffrey* | |
Herbst, Jennifer* | |
Hess, Rachel | |
Hiatt, Robert | |
Hickner, John | |
Higashi, Robin | |
Higgins, Diana | |
Hilden, David | |
Hilton, Lara | |
Hirsch, Calvin | |
Hockenberry, Jason | |
Hoerster, Katherine | |
Hoffman, Richard | |
Hoggatt, Katherine* | |
Holmes, John | |
Holmes-Maybank, Keri | |
Holt, Stephen | |
Holzman, Samuel | |
Hong, Arthur* | |
Hoody, Daniel | |
Horberg, Michael | |
Horvitz-Lennon, Marcela | |
Howell, Joel | |
Hsu, Douglas | |
Huang, Sean Shenghsiu | |
Huang, Yen-Ming | |
Hubley, Sam | |
Huddle, Thomas | |
Hudelson, Patricia | |
Hughes, John | |
Hughesch, Joel | |
Hughto, Jaclyn | |
Hunt, Stephen | |
Hunter, Alan | |
Huo, Jinhai (Stephen) | |
Hussey, Peter | |
Hutcheon, Doug | |
Hyman, David | |
Ilgen, Mark | |
Imbert, Elizabeth | |
Indovina, Kimberly* | |
Ippolito, Matthew | |
Isenberg, Sarina | |
Isik, Arda | |
Ivlev, Ilya | |
Izquierdo, Adriana | |
Jaccard, Evrim | |
Jackson, Christopher | |
Jacobson, Gretchen | |
Jacobson, Peter | |
Jan, Arif* | |
Jatwani, Shraddha* | |
Jayes, Robert | |
Jegadeesan, Ramprasad | |
Jenkins, Tania* | |
Ji, Xu | |
Jih, Jane | |
Johnson, Karin | |
Johnson, Tracy | |
Johnson, William | |
Johnston, C Bree | |
Jonas, Wayne B. | |
Jones, Barbara | |
Jones, Christine | |
Jonk, Yvonne | |
Joseph, Robert | |
Kahn, Talia* | |
Kalkhoran, Sara | |
Kanady, Jennifer | |
Kangovi, Shreya | |
Kanter, Genevieve | |
Kantor, Molly | |
Kaphingst, Kimberly | |
Kara, Areeba | |
Karippot, Asha | |
Kashaf, Susan* | |
Katz, Marilyn | |
Kavati, Abhishek | |
Kay, Cynthia | |
Kearns, Mark | |
Keller, Paula | |
Keniston, Angela | |
Kennedy, Jae | |
Kennel, Jamie* | |
Kertesz, Stefan | |
Kesselheim, Aaron | |
Kester, Rachel | |
Khanagavi, Jagadish | |
Khateeb, Rafina | |
Khawaja, Imran | |
KheirEddine, Kerboua | |
Kiefer, Meghan | |
Kim, Hyunjee | |
Kim, Sarah | |
Kim, Sarang | |
Kimball, Sarah | |
King, Christopher | |
Kinosian, Bruce | |
Klap, Ruth | |
Klein, Jared* | |
Kleinman, Jack | |
Kneeland, Patrick | |
Knight, Kelly | |
Knoepke, Christopher | |
Kode, Karthik | |
Koizumi, Shunzo | |
Kolehmainen, Christine | |
Kong, Marianna | |
Konjeti, Venkata Rajesh | |
Kookal, Krishna Kumar | |
Koppaka, Ram | |
Kormos, William | |
Kortsch, Daniel | |
Kost, Amanda | |
Kottke, Thomas | |
Kovacs, Richard | |
Koven, Suzanne | |
Kraemer, Ryan | |
Krakoff, Lawrence | |
Kralewski, John | |
Kreyenbuhl, Julie | |
Krishnan, Jerry | |
Kroenke, Kurt | |
Kuhn, Kristi | |
Kwolek, Deborah | |
Kyle, Julia | |
Lacour-Chestnut, Frene | |
Ladapo, Joseph | |
Lagisetty, Pooja | |
Lakshminarayana, Pradeep | |
Lam, Christine | |
Lamantia, Michael | |
Lambert, David | |
Landler, Matthew | |
Landon, Bruce | |
Lands, Ronald | |
Lantos, John | |
Larson, Allison | |
Larson, Eric | |
Larson, Mary Jo | |
Latham, Heath | |
Latham, Kenzie | |
Laurion, Victor* | |
Lawrence, Karen | |
Lawrence, Robert | |
Laws, Barton | |
Laws, M. Barton | |
Leasure, Emily | |
Lee, Jessica | |
Lee, Jonathan | |
Lee, Shoou-Yih | |
Lee, Thomas | |
Lee, WeiWei | |
Leeds, Ira* | |
Leekha, Surbhi | |
Lefevre, Michael | |
Leslie, Douglas | |
Lessing, Juan | |
Levenson, Joshua | |
Levin-Scherz, Jeffrey | |
Levine, David | |
Lexchin, Joel | |
Liaw, Winston | |
Liebow, Mark | |
Lin, Grace | |
Lin, Lewei (Allison)* | |
Lind, Bonnie | |
Lindenberg, Julia* | |
Linder, Jeffrey | |
Lindner, Stephan | |
List, Justin | |
Litchfield, Ian | |
Liu, Haiyan | |
Lobo, Carroline* | |
Locke, Kenneth | |
Lombardi, Angela | |
Longo, Lisa | |
Lontos, Konstantinos | |
Lopresti, Charles | |
Loskutova, Natalia | |
Lum, Hillary | |
Lund, Brian | |
Lyles, Courtney | |
Mackinney, Theodore | |
Mafi, John* | |
Mahfood Haddad, Toufik | |
Makam, Anil | |
Makdissi, Regina | |
Malik, Manpreet | |
Mandal, Jennifer | |
Marantz, Paul | |
Margolis, Karen | |
Martell, Bridget | |
Martin, Shannon* | |
Martinez, Ashley* | |
Martinez, Lisa | |
Mastalerz, Katarzyna | |
Materson, Barry J. | |
Mathioudakis, Alexander G.* | |
Mattocks, Kristin | |
Mbah, Olive | |
Mcadam-Marx, Carrie* | |
Mccall-Hosenfeld, Jennifer | |
Mccarthy, AnneMarie | |
Mcclellan, Mark* | |
Mcconeghy, Kevin | |
Mccullough, Megan | |
Mcgillicuddy, Morgan* | |
Mcginnis, Kathleen | |
Mcintyre, Caley | |
Mcmahon Jr., Laurence | |
Mcnamara, Megan | |
Mcnicoll, Lynn | |
Mcwhorter, Ketrell | |
Medarametla, Venkatrao | |
Mehrotra, Ateev | |
Mehta, Kathan | |
Mehta, Neil | |
Meissner, Paul | |
Melzer, Anne* | |
Mendel, Peter | |
Menon, Anish | |
Merchant, Chandni | |
Meredith, Lisa | |
Merlin, Jessica | |
Meseeha, Marcelle | |
Meyers, David | |
Miake-Lye, Isomi* | |
Miller, Franklin | |
Mills, Lynnea | |
Miner, Sarah | |
Mints, Gregory | |
Mittadodla, Penchala | |
Mixon, Amanda | |
Modha, Kunjam | |
Mohan, Babu | |
Mohan, Deepika | |
Moin, Tannaz | |
Moise, Nathalie* | |
Montori, Victor | |
Morain, Stephanie | |
Morasco, Benjamin | |
Moreau, Jessica | |
Morgan, Robert | |
Morone, Natalia | |
Morris, Megan | |
Mosher, Hilary | |
Moss, Karen | |
Mourad, Michelle | |
Mueller, Michael | |
Mueller, Stephanie | |
Mukamel, Dana | |
Mull, Nikhil | |
Mundt, Marlon | |
Murimi, Irene | |
Murphy, Daniel | |
Murphy, Edward | |
Murphy, Jennifer | |
Murphy, Martina | |
Murray, Kenny* | |
Murray Horwitz, Mara | |
Nair, Devika | |
Nair, Jayamohan | |
Nambiar, Sudheer | |
Nambudiri, Vinod | |
Nandagopal, Lakshminarayanan | |
Nandiwada, Deepa Rani* | |
Narayan, K. M. Venkat | |
Nelson, Nick | |
Neufeld, Jonathan* | |
Neuner, Joan | |
Newby, Celeste | |
Newman, Jeff | |
Ng, Henry | |
Nguyen, Oanh | |
Nguyen, Theresa | |
Nichols, Linda | |
Nielsen, Craig | |
Nothelle, Stephanie | |
Ntzani, Evangelia | |
Nutan, Fnu | |
Núñez, Julio | |
O’dorisio, Nathan | |
O’malley, Ann | |
Ohri, Ritika | |
Oldfield, Benjamin* | |
Olivieri, Jason | |
Olshansky, Brian | |
Opole, Isaac | |
Opotowsky, Alexander | |
Orkaby, Ariela* | |
Orlander, Jay | |
Otis, John | |
Ott, Brian | |
Pace, Lydia* | |
Page, Stephanie | |
Painter, Jacob* | |
Paje, David | |
Palamara, Kerri | |
Pandey, Soumya | |
Pandit, Anjali | |
Paranjape, Anuradha | |
Parish, David | |
Park, Yoon Soo | |
Parks, Anna | |
Pasha, Amirala | |
Pasupula, Deepak Kumar | |
Patchett, David | |
Patel, Jignesh | |
Patel, Kanan | |
Patel, Mukundkumar | |
Paul, Vishesh | |
Pearlman, Robert | |
Pell, Jonathan | |
Pels, Richard | |
Penfold, Robert | |
Penney, Lauren* | |
Penrod, Joan | |
PerezJolles, Monica | |
Perissinotto, Carla | |
Petersen, Carolyn* | |
Petersen, Nancy | |
Petrillo, Laura* | |
Pfoh, Elizabeth* | |
Phelan, Sean | |
Phillips, Russell | |
Picchioni, Michael | |
Pierce, Cason | |
Pincavage, Amber | |
Pineda, Jessica* | |
Pittman, Patricia | |
Potter, Jennifer | |
Prabhakaran, Prasanth | |
Presley, Caroline | |
Press, Valerie | |
Priyanka, Priyanka | |
Probst, Marc | |
Pronk, Nico | |
Psek, Wayne* | |
Pullalarevu, Raghavesh | |
Puri, Isha | |
Quinn, Roswell | |
Rabatin, Joseph | |
Radhakrishnan, Archana | |
Radomski, Thomas | |
Raebel, Marsha | |
Raffel, Katie | |
Raggio, Greer | |
Ramachandran, Ambili | |
Ramakrishnan, Praveen | |
Rana, Aadia | |
Rao, Shobha | |
Rasheed, Khalid | |
Ratanawongsa, Neda | |
Raue, Patrick | |
Raven, Maria | |
Ray, Kristin | |
Razack, Saleem | |
Read, Andrew | |
Reddy, Ashok | |
Reddy, Krishna | |
Reed, Mary* | |
Reese, Jennifer | |
Regenstein, Marsha | |
Reinke, Lynn | |
Reuben, David | |
Rhee, Greg | |
Rhoades, Dorothy | |
Rhodes, Ramona | |
Ridgely, M Susan | |
Rinne, Seppo | |
Ripp, Jonathan | |
Roberts, Eric* | |
Robertson, Christopher | |
Robinson, Jehni | |
Rodriguez, Michael | |
Rollman, Bruce | |
Rosen, Marc* | |
Rosenbaum, Sara | |
Rosenbloom, Samuel | |
Rosenblum, Michael* | |
Rosenthal, Daniel | |
Rosland, Ann-Marie | |
Ross, Joseph | |
Rossom, Rebecca | |
Roth, Katalin | |
Roy, Michael | |
Ruben, Mollie | |
Rubinstein, Yaffa | |
Rudd, Mariah | |
Rudolph, Mark | |
Ruggero, Camilo | |
Ryvicker, Miriam | |
Saag, Harry | |
Sabik, Lindsay | |
Saigh, Orit | |
Sairenji, Tomoko | |
Salvador, Gabriel | |
Sampathkumar, Priya | |
Samuelson, Bethany | |
Sanders, Justin | |
Sandy, Lewis | |
Sanghai, Saket | |
Sangster, Janice | |
Sankhyan, Pratyaksha | |
Santhosh, Lekshmi | |
Santos, Michael* | |
Saraiya, Mona | |
Sarcone, Ellen | |
Sargsyan, Zaven | |
Sarkar, Urmimala | |
Satchidanand, Nikhil | |
Satre, Derek | |
Sattari, Maryam | |
Saudan, Patrick | |
Saunders, Robert | |
Saxe, Joanne | |
Schafhalter-Zoppoth, Ingeborg* | |
Schapira, Marilyn | |
Schectman, Joel* | |
Schiff, Gordon | |
Schnittker, Jason | |
Scholcoff, Cecilia* | |
Scholl, Isabelle | |
Schott, Christopher | |
Schreiner, Andrew | |
Schuwirth, Lambert | |
Schwartz, Mark | |
Seaman, Aaron | |
Seay, Julia | |
Segal, Gad | |
Seligman, Hilary | |
Selvin, Elizabeth | |
Sen, Aditi | |
Sethi, Jasobanta | |
Shaffer, Kelly | |
Shah, Ashish | |
Shah, Asif | |
Shah, Niyati* | |
Shah, Sachin | |
Shahraz, Saeid* | |
Sharma, Rashmi | |
Shaw, Jonathan | |
Shaw Tronieri, Jena* | |
Sheets, Kent | |
Sheets, Nathan | |
Shekelle, Paul | |
Shen, Megan | |
Sherman, Karen* | |
Shlamovitz, Gil | |
Shrestha, Sundar | |
Shroff, Swati |
References
Goodman SN, Berline J, Fletcher SW, Fletcher RH. Manuscript quality before and after peer review and editing at Annals of Internal Medicine. 1994; 121(1):11–21.
Shattell MM, Chinn P, Thomas S, Cowling WR. Authors’ and editors’ perspectives on peer review quality in three scholarly nursing journals. J Nurs Scholarsh. 2010;42(1):58–65.
Wager E, Middleton P. Effects of technical editing in biomedical journals: a systematic review. JAMA. 2002;287:2821–4.
Roberts JC, Fletcher RH, Fletcher SW. Effects of peer review and editing on the readability of articles published in Annals of Internal Medicine. JAMA. 1994;272:119–21
Jefferson T, Alderson P, Wager E, Davidoff F. Effects of editorial peer review: a systematic review. JAMA. 2002;287(21):2784–2786. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.287.21.2784.
Scholcoff C, Sanghani P, Jackson W, Egloff HM, Sawatsky AP, Jackson JL. Peer Review of Abstracts Submitted to An Internal Medicine National Meeting: Is it a predictor of future publication?, J Gen Intern Med. 2018;33(7):1002–1003.
Jackson JL, Srinivasan M, Rea J, Fletcher KE, Kravitz RL. The validity of peer review in a general medicine journal. PLoS One. 2011;6(7):e22475.
Kravitz RL, Franks P, Feldman MD, Gerrity M, Byrne C, et al. Editorial peer reviewers’ recommendations at a general medical journal: are they reliable and do editors care?, PLoS ONE. 2010;5(4): e10072. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0010072.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Jackson, J.L., Asch, S. & Bates, C. Peer Review at JGIM. J GEN INTERN MED 33, 2015–2021 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11606-018-4676-3
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11606-018-4676-3